
"One is torn between narration and categorization, between chronology and inventory.
What should be recognised here is that photographic books (and exhibitions), frequently cannot help but reproduce these rudimentary ordering schemes, and in so doing implicitly claim a share in both the authority and illusory neutrality of the archive. Herein lies the 'primitivism' of still photography in relation to the cinema. Unlike a film, a photographic book or exhibition can almost always be dissolved back into its component parts, back into the archive. The ensemble seem to be both provisional and artless. Thus, within the dominant culture of photography, we find a chain of dodges and denials: at any stage of photographic production the apparatus of selection and interpretation is liable to render itself invisible (or conversely to celebrate its own workings as a kind of moral crusade or creative magic)."
Allan Sekula, from 'Reading an Archive'
I'm a little late with my addition to
Andy Adams (
Flak Photo) and Resolve Blogs
'Future of Photobooks' discussion, but this quote seems like a relevant starting point. There are many different strands to the discussion - in terms of format, content, aesthetics and experimentation, but essentially my feelings on this topic are that the photobook is a certain format because photography lends itself to that format. I'm all for experimentation within that format- zines, self publishing, 'curated' books, and feel that this will be a natural evolution of the photo book, but essentially, I can't see the traditional book format; a designed tangible object, dying out, or in fact straying too far from what it has always been.
The discussion has thrown up some great places to look for independent photobooks, the first port of call being the
new blog started by Joerg Colberg of
Conscientious and
Mrs Deane. There's also Alec Soth's new venture,
Little Brown Mushroom. One of my favourite independent books that I have seen recently is
David Gray's Vampire, which is a 10x8" singer sewn book, and is accompanied by a 10x8" signed edition print.